Key takeaways
- Covers several legacy part numbers, reducing fitment guesswork for owners of older refrigerators
- Priced well below service-call costs, making DIY replacement economically rational
- Owners report occasional misalignment of the bail arm on arrival, requiring manual adjustment before first cycle
What's inside
When a Frigidaice maker stops producing cubes, the frustration is immediate and practical. No crushed ice in your drink, no full bin for entertaining, and a repair technician quote that can rival the cost of a replacement unit. The search for a solution to a “frigidaire ice maker not working” problem leads to two paths: swapping the internal assembly inside your refrigerator or adding a countertop machine that sidesteps the repair entirely. Owner feedback consistently highlights that the distinction between a good fix and a bad one comes down to compatibility certainty and cycle time, not brand prestige or feature lists.
What separates a worthwhile purchase from a regrettable one is whether the part or machine actually fits your situation. A replacement assembly that requires disassembly beyond your comfort level defeats the purpose. A countertop unit with poor insulation melts your output before you pour a second glass. Across all eight options below, we compared published specifications, price points, and recurring themes from owner reviews to identify which products genuinely solve the problem and which ones create new ones.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date shown and are subject to change.
Quick Picks
| Product | Best for | Price |
|---|---|---|
| 241798231 Replacement Assembly | Direct OEM-spec replacement | $43.99 |
| Countertop Portable 26 lb | Whole-house ice independence | $83.64 |
| IM116000 Assembly Kit | DIY refrigerator repair | $74 |
| 26 lb Portable Compact (Stainless) | Best aesthetic countertop unit | $99.99 |
| 241798231 Assembly Kit | Genuine Frigidaire part confidence | $81.58 |
| 241798224/241798231 Ice Maker | Tightest budget repair | $40.99 |
| EFIC128AMZBLK Compact | Space-constrained countertop setup | $69.99 |
| IM117000 Ice Maker Kit | Newest OEM kit availability | $99.99 |
How We Picked
For this category, four criteria carry disproportionate weight. First, compatibility accuracy: a replacement assembly must match your exact refrigerator model, and owner complaints cluster heavily around mismatched fitment. Second, ice production rate versus real-world output: listed pound-per-day figures rarely reflect sustained performance, so we flagged models where owners reported significant shortfall. Third, installation complexity relative to price: a budget part that demands professional help is not actually budget. Fourth, build durability signals: recurring mentions of cracked trays, failed water inlet valves, or mold-prone reservoirs disqualify otherwise attractive options.
The 8 Best Frigidaire Ice Maker Not Working in 2026
241798231 Replacement Assembly
This is the go-to part for owners who have confirmed the failed component is the ice maker module itself rather than the water supply or freezer thermostat. At $43.99, it replaces multiple OEM numbers including 241642511 and 241642501, which broadens its compatibility across Frigidaire, Electrolux, and Kenmore refrigerator lines without requiring a model-by-model hunt.
- Covers several legacy part numbers, reducing fitment guesswork for owners of older refrigerators
- Priced well below service-call costs, making DIY replacement economically rational
- Owners report occasional misalignment of the bail arm on arrival, requiring manual adjustment before first cycle
Skip this if your refrigerator is a current-generation model with a proprietary ice maker design; the listing explicitly notes it is not universal, and forcing compatibility wastes money and time.
Countertop Portable 26 lb (Black Stainless Steel)
For anyone whose built-in ice maker is not just broken but structurally problematic—leaking, jammed, or awaiting a weeks-long part backorder—this countertop unit at $83.64 provides immediate relief. It produces bullet ice at a rate of 26 pounds per day, which is adequate for a household of three or four without running the machine continuously.
- Self-contained operation means zero plumbing or freezer dependency
- Black stainless finish resists fingerprints better than glossy alternatives in the same price tier
- Bullet ice shape dissolves faster in warm drinks, a trade-off for speed of production
Skip this if you primarily serve cocktails or iced coffee where cube shape and slow melt are non-negotiable.
IM116000 Assembly Kit
At $74, this white assembly kit targets owners of mid-range Frigidaire refrigerator lines where the OEM part number matches directly. The kit form factor includes mounting hardware, which matters because stripped or missing screws are among the most common reasons a DIY ice maker swap turns into a frustrating project.
- Complete kit approach reduces the chance of needing supplementary fasteners or adapters
- White housing blends seamlessly inside the freezer compartment without visual contrast issues
- Some owners note the water inlet connector is a tight fit on older refrigerator supply lines
Skip this if your refrigerator model predates the IM116000 part designation; cross-referencing with Frigidaire’s parts database is essential before ordering.
26 lb Portable Compact Maker (Stainless, Medium)
The $99.99 price tag places this stainless-steel unit at the premium end of the countertop category, but the build quality justifies it for owners who want a machine that looks intentional on a kitchen counter rather than like a temporary fix. It matches the 26-pound-per-day output of cheaper competitors while adding a more robust compressor and insulation package.
- Stainless construction with medium form factor balances capacity against counter footprint
- Better thermal retention keeps ice from clumping during brief storage between cycles
- At the highest price in this roundup, the value proposition narrows if you only need ice intermittently
Skip this if a basic countertop unit would meet your needs and the aesthetic premium is not a priority.
241798231 Assembly Kit
This $81.58 option is the genuine Frigidaire-branded version of the part number covered by the first entry. The price difference of roughly $38 over the aftermarket replacement is the core question: are you paying for a guaranteed-spec component, or is the aftermarket equivalent sufficient? Owner feedback suggests the OEM version ships with tighter dimensional tolerances, which reduces the bail-arm alignment issues that plague cheaper alternatives.
- Direct Frigidaire branding provides confidence in material and electrical specification accuracy
- Reduces fitment risk for owners who have already had one replacement arrive slightly off-spec
- Approximately $38 more than functionally similar aftermarket assemblies
Skip this if your budget is tight and you are comfortable performing a manual bail-arm adjustment after installation.
241798224/241798231 Refrigerator Ice Maker
At $40.99, this is the lowest-cost entry that still covers the most common Frigidaire and Kenmore part numbers. For owners treating the repair as a temporary measure—perhaps while waiting for an expensive refrigerator replacement to be scheduled—this price is hard to argue against.
- Lowest barrier to entry for a self-directed repair without professional labor
- Compatible with the two most widely produced Frigidaire ice maker part numbers
- Material quality is visibly lower than OEM alternatives, with thinner plastic trays reported by owners
Skip this if you plan to keep your refrigerator for several more years; the durability trade-off becomes apparent after repeated freeze-thaw cycles.
EFIC128AMZBLK Compact Countertop
This $69.99 black compact unit is the middle ground in the countertop segment—more affordable than the stainless premium option while offering the same 26-pound-per-day rated output. Its compact footprint suits apartment kitchens or rental properties where counter real estate is genuinely limited.
- Smallest physical footprint among the countertop options without sacrificing rated daily production
- Matte black exterior conceals water spots better than stainless or white alternatives
- Owners note the ice basket is shallow, requiring more frequent emptying into a storage container
Skip this if you host gatherings regularly and need a larger integrated ice bin rather than a compact production-and-transfer workflow.
IM117000 Ice Maker Kit
The $99.99 IM117000 is Frigidaire’s newest OEM kit designation, positioned for refrigerator models where the older IM116000 no longer applies. As a genuine replacement part, it represents the manufacturer’s current engineering revision, which owners report includes improved mold resistance in the tray material compared to prior generations.
- Latest OEM iteration with reported material improvements addressing older mold and cracking complaints
- One-size listing simplifies ordering for models explicitly designated as IM117000-compatible
- Highest part price in this roundup, with diminishing returns over the $74 IM116000 if your model accepts both
Skip this if your refrigerator accepts the IM116000; the additional $26 is not justified unless Frigidaire’s parts diagram specifies IM117000 exclusively.
Buying Guide
Part Number Verification Before Everything
The single most important step in resolving a “frigidaire ice maker not working” problem is identifying the correct part number inside your freezer. Frigidaire has used at least four distinct ice maker assemblies across recent model years, and visual similarity does not guarantee interchangeability. Check your refrigerator’s model tag, then cross-reference with the parts diagram before ordering any assembly, kit, or replacement module.
Countertop Output Ratings Versus Real Sustained Production
Every countertop unit in this roundup claims 26 pounds per day, but that figure assumes the machine runs continuously through its harvest cycle without interruption. In practice, the first batch is slower while the compressor reaches operating temperature, and ambient kitchen humidity affects how long ice holds its shape in the basket. Treat rated output as an upper bound, not a guarantee.
Installation Skill Required and the True Cost of DIY
Replacing an internal ice maker assembly requires removing the freezer shelf, disconnecting a water line, unthreading one or two mounting screws, and seating a connector correctly. Owners consistently report that a mismatched connector or a pinched water line causes immediate leaks. If you are not comfortable with basic hand tools and a screwdriver sequence, budget the difference toward a handyman rather than risking water damage to flooring or cabinetry.
Our Verdict
For owners confident in a refrigerator part swap, the 241798231 Replacement Assembly at $43.99 offers the strongest value-to-compatibility ratio, covering multiple legacy part numbers without a premium OEM markup. For the tightest possible budget repair, the 241798224/241798231 Ice Maker at $40.99 gets the job done with slightly thinner materials. And if your repair has stalled indefinitely and you need ice tomorrow, the Countertop Portable at $83.64 eliminates dependency on the broken unit entirely—making it the best choice when time matters more than part-specific correctness.
FAQ
Why is my Frigidaire ice maker not working but the refrigerator still cold?
The ice maker operates on a separate electrical circuit and mechanical cycle from the cooling system. A faulty water inlet valve, a jammed ejector arm, or a failed ice maker thermostat can all halt ice production while the compressor continues running normally.
Can I use an aftermarket ice maker assembly instead of an OEM part?
Many aftermarket assemblies match the original dimensions and electrical connectors, and owner reports on the 241798231 variants confirm functional equivalence. The trade-off is typically in plastic density and long-term crack resistance, not immediate performance.
How often should I replace my Frigidaire ice maker assembly?
There is no fixed interval; assemblies typically last between several years and the life of the refrigerator. Early failure signals include misshapen cubes, incomplete harvests, or visible cracks in the tray—any of which justify replacement before the unit fails completely.
Is a countertop ice maker a permanent solution or a workaround?
It depends on your situation. If your refrigerator’s ice maker line is structurally damaged or the replacement part is discontinued, a countertop unit is a permanent and fully functional solution. If you simply want ice while waiting for a part to ship, it serves as an effective bridge.
Write Your Review
No reviews yet. Be the first to share your experience!